A French naval commander, Captain Jacques Launay, recently stunned defense observers by confirming that Indian Rafale aircraft were shot down during the May 6‑7, 2025 aerial clash with Pakistan.
According to him, the losses were not due to the superiority of Chinese-made fighters, but Pakistan’s tactical edge and better handling of a complex situation.
Speaking at an Indo‑Pacific conference in France, Launay stated that more than 140 fighter jets from both countries engaged in that night’s battle, creating a crowded airspace that made every target vulnerable. He praised Pakistan for being “much better prepared” and using that chaotic environment to its advantage.
Addressing questions about Rafale’s radar performance, Captain Launay said the issue was not technical, but operational: “There was nothing wrong with the war machine, but the machine was not used properly.” He insisted that when deployed correctly, Rafales remain extremely capable, even against advanced aircraft like the Chinese J‑10C.
The commander also revealed that India is interested in acquiring a naval version of the Rafale, capable of carrier operations, which can reportedly carry nuclear weapons.
Launay, who has over 25 years of experience flying Rafales, added credibility to his assessment. He supervises operations at France’s Landivisiau Naval Air Base, which maintains a fleet of Rafales, nuclear submarines, and warships.
While Indian officials continue to deny any losses, Launay’s remarks echo earlier reports from French intelligence confirming at least one downed Rafale.
The statement has added weight to Pakistan’s claims, underscoring how pilot skill and strategy can outweigh pure technological specs in modern aerial warfare.
